How Airbnb Management Companies Set Prices (and Why It Matters More Than You Think)

Pricing is one of the biggest drivers of Airbnb performance, yet it’s also one of the most misunderstood parts of hosting.

Many owners assume pricing is simply about setting a nightly rate and letting bookings roll in. In reality, pricing decisions affect occupancy, average nightly rate, visibility on Airbnb, review scores and momentum, and total annual income.

This is why professional Airbnb management companies put so much focus on pricing strategy and why it plays such a large role in whether an Airbnb business succeeds or underperforms.

This article explains how Airbnb management companies really set prices, what affects Airbnb performance, and why pricing matters far more than most hosts realise.

How do Airbnb management companies set prices?

At a high level, Airbnb pricing is built from three layers working together:

1. Dynamic pricing tools
2. Market and demand knowledge
3. Human revenue management expertise

Strong performance comes from combining all three. Relying on just one rarely delivers consistent results.

1. Dynamic pricing tools: the foundation, not the finish line

Many professional Airbnb management companies use dynamic pricing software. These tools adjust nightly rates automatically based on factors such as:

• Demand in the local area
• Lead time before arrival
• Day of the week
• Seasonality
• Historical booking patterns
• Comparable listings

Used properly, pricing tools help avoid static pricing and respond to market changes far faster than a manual approach.

However, pricing tools work best when they are configured and guided by people who understand short-term rental performance, rather than left to run in isolation.

The difference is not the tool itself, but how well it is set up and monitored.

2. What actually affects Airbnb performance beyond price alone

Pricing does not exist in a vacuum. Airbnb’s platform responds to a wider set of performance signals, including:

• Booking conversion rate
• Availability and calendar openness
• Review scores and recency
• Response speed and reliability
• Guest experience consistency

Pricing decisions influence all of these.

For example:

• Pricing too high can reduce bookings, harming conversion and visibility.
• Pricing too low can fill the calendar but suppress total income.
• Poor pricing around peak demand can leave substantial revenue unrealised.

This is why experienced Airbnb managers think in terms of total performance, not just nightly rate.

3. Local demand and event-driven pricing

One of the biggest differences between strong and weak pricing strategies is how well local demand is understood.

In areas like Cheltenham, pricing during major events such as the Cheltenham Festival can change dramatically, not just in the town itself but in surrounding areas.

Demand patterns are not uniform:

• Some nearby towns see significant uplift
• Others are only lightly affected
• Travel distance, transport links, and guest behaviour all matter

Understanding when to push rates, when to protect occupancy, and when to prioritise longer stays requires local market awareness layered onto pricing tools.

4. Why pricing strategy is not just about peak nights

Many hosts focus on maximising peak weekends and holidays. While these periods matter, long-term performance is often shaped by:

• Shoulder seasons
• Midweek occupancy
• Short lead-time gaps
• Last-minute cancellations
• Length-of-stay optimisation

Strong pricing strategies aim to:

• Smooth occupancy across the year
• Reduce unbooked gaps
• Protect average nightly rate without sacrificing volume

This approach usually leads to higher annual income, even if individual nights are sometimes priced more conservatively.

5. Addressing the two biggest owner pricing fears

When owners think about pricing, two concerns come up repeatedly.

Fear one: pricing too low and leaving money on the table

This usually comes from seeing neighbouring listings with higher advertised rates.

Fear two: pricing too high and hurting occupancy

This often follows quieter periods or gaps in the calendar.

Good Airbnb pricing management balances both by:

• Using data to guide decisions
• Adjusting prices as demand signals change
• Reviewing performance regularly rather than reacting emotionally

The goal is not to win every night, but to optimise the year as a whole.

6. Why pricing expertise matters as much as the tools

The most effective Airbnb management companies treat pricing as an ongoing discipline, not a one-time setup.

That means:

• Selecting high-quality pricing tools
• Configuring them with market-specific rules
• Applying short-term rental revenue management knowledge
• Monitoring performance and adjusting when needed

At Red Kite Hosts, pricing decisions are informed by hands-on experience across multiple platforms, regular performance reviews, and insights gained through industry events such as Airbnb’s Superhost and host summits.

This layered approach helps ensure pricing supports both strong occupancy and strong returns.

Final thoughts: pricing is performance strategy

Pricing is not just about filling a calendar. It shapes how Airbnb’s algorithm views your listing, how guests perceive value, and how your property performs over time.

For owners running an Airbnb business, especially in competitive UK markets, pricing strategy is one of the biggest levers available.

Handled well, it can quietly transform results. Handled poorly, it can hold a great property back.

If you want your Airbnb priced with intent rather than guesswork, professional management and experienced revenue oversight make a meaningful difference.

‍